The Caketeria
Custom cake shop that's been handling Newtown weddings and birthday orders since 2010, back when it went by Felix's Caketeria. The cannoli cream cake is the one to ask for, and the vegan cupcakes aren't an afterthought.
Cupcakes in the burbs
Every cupcakes spot we vouch for, across every town we cover. Cross a town line for the good ones. That's the whole point.
The picks
- The Caketeria
- Cup & Cake Company
- Dia Doce Gourmet Cupcakes and Coffee
- Karen's Sugar Love Bakery
- Papa's Cupcakes
- Velvet Sky Bakery
Cup & Cake Company
Scratch-made cupcakes out of a Main Street Marketplace storefront, hours posted week to week on Instagram. Check before you make the trip — this one keeps its own schedule.
Dia Doce Gourmet Cupcakes and Coffee
Cupcakes by the dozen on South High Street, with coffee to go alongside. Flavors rotate and the frosting is not shy.
Karen's Sugar Love Bakery
Karen turns out custom cakes, cupcakes, and cookies from a small shop on Washington Ave. Order ahead for anything with a candle in it.
Papa's Cupcakes
Papa bakes every one of these himself, which is both the shop's name and its whole premise. Weddings and birthdays keep him busiest, and the doors stay shut Monday and Tuesday, so this is a call-ahead kind of place.
Velvet Sky Bakery
A Jenkintown bakery on Leedom Street doing custom cakes and cupcakes, wedding work included. Order ahead for the big stuff.
That filters out everything
Drop a filter or clear the search. Everything on this page made the cut.
Show everything